A09 Good Arguments - HKU Philosophy The following is a valid form of argument: "If P, then Q. So not-P." Some students initially have difficulty understanding why this is a valid form of argument. Now suppose for the sake of argument that P is true. Still, the program has just played 20 games against Gary Kasparov and it won every game, 10 as white and 10 as black. So, here is our final definition of a good argument A good argument is an argument that is either valid or strong, and with plausible premises that are true, do not beg the question, and are relevant to the conclusion. Now that you know what a good argument is, you should be able to explain why these claims are mistaken.

Compelling Argumentative Essay Topics - ServiceScape The computer scientist claims to have a mathematical proof that his program will always win, but the proof runs to 500 pages of dense mathematical symbols, and no one has yet been able to verify it. Whatever kind of argument you choose to write about, always be sure to back up your claims with good research and facts. What we're looking for in an argumentative essay topic is something that might expand people's.

What is a good argument? He's arguing that the contradiction is something that follows from his opponent's view. (I got this wonderful example from my colleague Tim Maudlin.) A computer scientist announces that he's constructed a computer program that can play the perfect game of chess: he claims that this program is guaranteed to win every game it plays, whether it plays black or white, with never a loss or a draw, and against any opponent whatsoever. A person who presents an argument is trying to convince you of something. A good argument is one in which the premises give good reasons to believe the.